Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Can Fantasy Hockey Save the NHL?

I try to pay attention to the NHL. No really...I do. The problem is that I was born and raised in Connecticut and anyone familiar with Hockey in the northeast knows what that means. It's been ten years now, but the faithful fans in Hartford haven't forgotten Peter Karmanos' evil doings which led to the departure of the beloved Whalers. This post is not meant to cry about the Whalers (another post-another time), because Connecticut isn't the exception, but the rule in terms of Hockey interest in the United States. Listen, I'm no Hockey expert, but that's the point. The NHL needs passionate sports fans with a passing interest in Hockey to have more reason to watch their sport. This is why Fantasy Hockey needs a complete overhaul.

A few weeks back when the NHL season got underway...what's that?...yeah, the season already started...don't worry, you're not the only one who had no idea. So like I was saying, I signed up for a Yahoo Fantasy Hockey team just for sh*ts & giggles mostly, but also to force myself to follow the NHL season. Right from the start, I realized this was going to be much more difficult than I initially realized. First of all, it's impossible to pronounce more than half the league. With the exception of Sid the Kid (the only recognizable player by 95% of the non-hockey sports population), the best players are all foreign. In other words, a live draft is out of the question. After all, can you imagine trying to pronounce names like Alexander Ovechkin or Miikka Kiprusoff for two or more hours?

If by some miracle you actually got through the draft process, then you'd have to deal with the impossible task of establishing a scoring system. If I were in charge, my first order of business would be to make sure Goaltenders are treated just like pitchers in Fantasy Baseball. Goals Against Average is the same as Earned Run Average, with Wins & Losses other obvious categories. Just like in baseball, Shutouts should earn some sort of bonus points as well.

Offensive categories need to be kept as simple as possible in hopes of keeping the interest of the average fan. Goals, Assists and...umm...uhh...here we run into a major dilemma. There's not enough categories and how do our Defensemen gain any stats? That's where the fighting could come into play. Fights, Fights Won, and Knockouts would all be categories worth looking into. I have no idea how to keep track of the (+/- ) or what any of it means, and I don't think I'm alone. I realize some leagues keep track of shots on goal as a category, but that makes little sense to me. That's like rewarding a QB for incomplete passes or a Shooting Guard for missed jump shots. Finally, what in the Holy Hell are the 'PIMP' stats? PIM & PPP are both listed as categories in my Yahoo league, but I haven't the slightest clue what either of those are. I don't know if they are a good thing, a bad thing, or if somebody is just making these things up at this point. My suggestion is to dumb-down everything when it comes to Fantasy Hockey and then maybe we can work from there. Our country is enthralled by fantasy sports and this could be the only way to save the NHL at this point. Oh yeah, and bring back the Whale!

19 comments:

Neil Joshi said...

Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Alexander Ovechkin are the only things that can save hockey.

craig gass said...

i think my head exploded reading this. fantasy hockey save the league? really?

RJ said...

PIM- Penalty Minutes. It's the better way of using your Fights and Knockouts system. Players that get 5 minute majors for fighting are valuable, and a player that can score and gets PIMs are suddenly important. A guy like Sean Avery is actually worth something, even if he is pond scum.

Penalty minutes are also one way Defensemen are worth something.

PPP is Power Play Points.

Shutouts are a stat category in most leagues.

Also, faceoff percentage or faceoffs won is a good stat if you really need it.

It's not that hard. Now Fantasy NASCAR... that takes some time.

Jon said...

Penalty Minutes and Power Play Points? Really? Can't track plus minus? Were you on the ice when your team scored? +1. Were you on the ice when the other team scored? -1.

PPP and SHP are so people will target specialists in the draft, folks who get on when their team is up a man or down a man. PIM is so that goons also have a place on your bench, and is why Chris Simon is the Holy Grail in fantasy hockey.

Goalies ~ Pitchers.. that makes good sense and I'd use that analogy to help your buddies understand. But if you've watched a hockey game, you know that the hotshots come out on the powerplay, and the defensive specialists come out on the penalty kill. So in fantasy, to excel in those categories, you target both.

In general, with players having a much longer shelf life than in other sports, keeper leagues are where it's at. Recruiting Carey Price or Jordan Staal and riding him to the natural conclusion of his career for years of fantasy dominance.

You guys invented Baseball* and you can't suss out something like penalty minutes or plus/minus? Come on. SLG is a way weirder stat than SHG.

Shorty said...

Just for the record...I do know what the PIM & PPP stats stand for...I was just trying to make a point that most people who don't follow hockey have no clue what those things mean...

thanx for reading...

Jeff said...

It ain't that hard — SHG's reward accurate shooters.

Any shot counted a SHG (shot on goal) means that it would have been a goal in it weren't for some effort by the goalie. So unless it's a limp-wristed lob from the red line, more shots mean more scoring chances from rebounds and scrums in the crease, which means more goals. Except if you're the Rangers shooting on Rick Dipietro.

So every SHG is a potential goal. Some less so and some more so, but every SHG is always a POTENTIAL GOAL. In the words of every hockey coach I've ever had, "Hit the [random expletive] net."

Matt P. said...

It's definitely an interesting premise. I've always been a baseball fan, but really only focused on the Phillies until I started playing fantasy baseball. Now I have a weird thing for the AL Central and have a much better appreciation for what's going on outside of the NL East.

I've thought about playing fantasy hockey just to gain that same added appreciation of the non-Flyers, and the same for English Premier League soccer. I decided against both because I'd rather have a Reality girlfriend, and I think she'd have hit the bricks if I mentioned a fantasy hockey team.

Really enjoyed your post.

Waters said...

If you already knew what PIM & PPP stand for then why did you bother writing this?

If you don't have any interest in hockey, or the IQ to pronounce 'foreign' names then why bother playing fantasy hockey?

Maybe you're just trying to make a point that the NHL is not as popular as say, the NFL, and for that I truly thank you for opening my eyes to the truth. I was under the impression that everyone in the world loved hockey. I'll forward this article on to the commissioner on your behalf, he'll be so devastated to hear the news.

Shane Giroux said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Shane Giroux said...

Deleted post above to correct typos:

The point was not about him not understanding, it was about average people not understanding.

I used to not give a crap about football. But then I got into fantasy football and find myself watching games every weekend.

Shorty said...

Thanks Shane...glad some of you got the point of the post...I guess it's hard for Die-Hard Hockey fans to swallow the fact that their sport is in ruins in our country. I was only trying to suggest a way to get more fans interested, but the Die-Hard Hockey fan seems too stubborn to accept this...

deez said...

the most comments i have ever seen on your blog and its about hockey! you must be doing something right shorty!!!!!

Shorty said...

It's all about the links Deez...

Thanx to Signal To Noise & Deadspin as well as anyone else who linked to this post!

Jon said...

To the commenter above. Some leagues do track shots, but SHG stands for Short Handed Goals. Scoring a goal when your team has a penalty.

Gabe Stein said...

Nice article. I think fantasy hockey could be one of the deeper games if done properly, and it would help the NHL somewhat. However, your article got me thinking about other ways to save the NHL (because fantasy hockey won't be enough) and so I wrote, well it's not really a response, but an expansion of the "how to save the NHL" point here: http://denversportszone.com/index.php/2007/10/16/saving-hockey

Anonymous said...

Christ Shorty, did you link this post directly to the TSN home page...you have half of Canada responding to this post (I know there's more than 10 people in Canada, but there are not more of 10 people in Canada who can read and type, so I guess I should say "half of literate Canada").

As far as your fantasy hockey analysis goes, +/- is about the most important stat for individual players (it was the only stat the coaches ever posted in my high school and college locker rooms). In addition, shots on goal as a stat is not analogous to missed jumpers and incomplete passes. A shot on goal in hockey is much more difficult to come by than either a jump shot or a pass, and there really is no such thing as a bad shot on goal.

Oh, and as far as the Canucks who replied by getting on you for not being able to pronounce the names of, or relate to, all the foreign (non-North American) players in league, I'll say this...the biggest problem with hockey right now is the percentage of foreign players in the league. Americans just can't relate. Let's face it, almost all of the foreign born players have names that make them sound like members of the Polit Bureau (communists for those who don't know what the Polit Bureau is), and those aren't the types of images you're standard Philadelphian, New Yorker, or Bostonian are looking to get behind.

Oh, and the foreigners in the League are not to blame...we North American hockey players are. If we were better, they wouldn't be here.

Gib

Shorty said...

Ahhh...Gibby...finally...proud of me for this one though, aren't ya? Who would have thought I could get this much feedback from a Hockey post?

Anonymous said...

I'm always proud of my little protege...after reading this post in particular.

Kudos Smitty.

Gib

Anonymous said...

Ignorant, lazy mofos. It wouldn't hurt if you check the league settings and it wouldtell you what everything stands for and what they mean.